Formula Ford: Brands Hatch Review
Filed under: Formula Ford,Race Reports,Testing on August 18, 2009
Brands Hatch was another disappointing and frustrating weekend for me. The car overheated in qualifying, got hotter in the first race and then even hotter in the second, eventually culminating in another retirement. Regrettably, it is now mathematically impossible to win the Midland South Formula Ford Championship – even if I were to win both of the final two races at Mallory Park in September. It is now time to start thinking about what we do for the end of season trophy events (Formula Ford Festival and Walter Hayes Trophy) – and that might mean missing them altogether.
Going into qualifying I was quietly optimistic that we would have a good session. Despite managing only 20-laps in testing on Wednesday after the clutch seals went, I have always enjoyed the Brands Hatch circuit and was looking forward to the first real weekend after winning at Mallory Park. However, my session was interrupted by a plug lead which had worked its way loose (creating a misfire) but after I rejoined I did a time good enough for sixth on the grid. This again was not quite what I had expected but considering it was another broken session, I was content none the less.
I was anticipating the races would be quite close – Brands Hatch is a difficult circuit on which to overtake for any category. After getting a decent start, I tucked in behind Cormac O’Neil in fifth place and followed him closely for the opening laps. I was slowly losing his tow but there was a breadth of air opening between myself and the following car of Adam Quartermaine. I felt faster through Paddock, Druids and Graham Hill but I wasn’t 100% sure where exactly I was losing out. Upon reflection, this suggests it was straight line speed.
At around lap seven, my engine temperature rose considerably to 100 degrees. Being conscious of possible serious damage I began short shifting gear changes to keep the revs low and generally driving slower. I was aware that if I was to DNF this weekend, my championship would be over. After a couple of laps at this speed, Quartermaine had closed up and was now looking to pass me. I held on for as long as I could, now with water temperature spiking at at almost 110 degrees but Quartermaine inevitably passed on the start and finish straight.
It was only two further laps before the race was stopped due to an accident at Clearways and I coasted my way back to the pits to finish seventh overall.
After examining the car we were at a loss as to what had caused such severe overheating. This new Scholar engine has always run hot and has never delivered the power it promised. Since Anglesey we have been trying to cool it down having tried new radiators, holes in bodywork, water wetter and everything we could think of. The radiator cap seal was broken, perhaps this was causing the water system to de-pressurise (at which point water would boil at a lower temperature)? This was changed as a precaution before race two.
The grid for race two was determined by the finishing positions for race one and I would start on the fourth row. I made another decent start and formed the back of a seven car train to the lead, behind Quartermaine, O’Neil and Parr. After a couple of laps and a few failed opportunities to get past, Quartermaine ran wide on the entry to Paddock and I slipped up the inside to move up a place. There was now a brief gap up to O’Neil which I managed to close fairly quickly. Malvern was leading but appeared slower than those chasing and Butcher, Grady, Parr, O’Neil and myself were all nose to tail behind him. Whilst I felt faster than the cars ahead of me, I couldn’t see an opportunity to make a pass – I would lose ground between Clearways and Paddock but then catch back up before the exit of Graham Hill.
The next time around, O’Neil spun on fluid whilst turning into Graham Hill Bend and I moved up to fifth position. At this point it was clear that the overheating had returned. Once again, I backed off to try and let the engine cool for a couple of laps but before long I was shown the Black and Orange flag for a mechanical problem and forced to retire to the pits. The Clerks felt that the fluid on the circuit was from my car and whilst I do not know if this was the case (it felt more like oil on the track not water to me), if it was, I can only apologise to those it affected. Had I finished the race, there was an opportunity for at least a podium as championship contenders (and race leaders) Butcher and Malvern finally had their inevitable championship collision at Graham Hill Bend on the penultimate lap.
And so that signalled the end to a very difficult, frustrating day. It is hard to imagine that there isn’t now lasting damage to the engine (piston rings and head gasket) and so if it was bad before, it is now worse. Our first Scholar engine lasted just 50 miles before the crankshaft broke and destroyed the block and now this one has been down on power and overheating right from day one. It really is heartbreaking considering Rory Butcher also runs with a Scholar that even Alan Wardropper admits is “exceptional” when it comes to horsepower.
For me, it is a shame for we are now no longer able to win the Midland South Championship. I have to admit, whilst I realise that in some ways it is due to circumstances (the Pembrey National rounds were cancelled and replaced by the Brands Hatch Midland South rounds becoming National, plus the Donington Park race being cancelled) it is a shame that in the Midland South Championship there are fewer non-National rounds than there are National (5:4). Effectively, that has unintentionally put bias towards competitors who score well at National meetings but don’t enter stand alone Midland South rounds.
We have persevered with our Swift SC94 and its engine all year and on reflection I think we have done well to achieve what we have. However, is it worth entering the Formula Ford Festival and Walter Hayes Trophy with the car in its present state? As it stands, it is hard to imagine achieving anything more than a top ten in either. I cannot afford an engine rebuild and our lack of testing this season has meant we never have fully addressed the cars handling characteristics. It’s frustrating because I feel I am driving well, better even than in 2007 but without the platform to show it.
Thanks again to everyone who helped me this weekend and those who came to support and spectate! Thanks also to David Galpin for the photographs!
No related posts.















Comments
Dominic Malvern
August 18th, 2009
Martin,
I am truly sorry for your misfortune this weekend; I know you and your team work hard and it would be nice to see your results reflecting that. We are not actually contesting the Midland South championship, only the National so have no reason to begridge you success in that competition.
The inevitable championship coming together as you put it was unfortunately down to a desperate manouvere on the part of Rory Butcher who was frustrated at not being able to pass Scott despite his obvious superior engine performance. He also attempted to pass Scott around the outside at Paddock by using the “old circuit” beyonnd the white line which had been outlawed by the officials as a black flag offence but no punishment was handed out. Nor was it for the offence that caused the coming together which we have on video which clearly shows Rory taking to the grass at Graham Hill bend in an attempt to pass Scott, losing control, spinning and hitting the rear of Scotts car as a result of that spin. Amazingly although receiving a severe reprimand for the offence no time penalty was administred so he retained the advantage he gained unfairly over Scott by finishing third with Scott in 4th. The officials (MSA Steward & Clerk of Course were less than helpful towards us!)
We wish you luck at Mallory if you do it. I haven’t looked at the M/S points situation but perhaps a class championship title is achievable even if overall honours have slipped beyond reach?
Best of luck
Dominic
Alan Forster
August 19th, 2009
Hi Martin
Really gutted for you, you must have some better luck coming your way soon.
Just a thought, I have experienced the same problem on a couple of race cars and the two problems (lack of power and overheating) were both related. The issue was the iginition timing not being correct (not necessarily static but also related to ignition advance) which caused it to be too far advanced (so not pinking hence it wasn’t immediately obvious it was ignition). Definately sounds the same to me, might be worth a shot.
Best of luck.
Alan
Martin Galpin
August 19th, 2009
@Alan – We had considered this. However, on the Kent engine it needs to be set on the dyno and so as Carroll Smith says, you shouldn’t have to check your ignition timing because if the timing is not correct, you need to find another engine builder. Of course, that doesn’t mean it’s not correct!
@Dominic – It was unfortunate to have ended like that. I wish you the best for Mondello Park. I would think you must be feeling pretty confident in Ireland?
Leave a Comment